ScrappleFace on Katrina and Big Government
December 31, 2006 by Laura | Trackback URI
We knew Scott Ott was brilliant, as his many parodies have so deftly illustrated. But this thoughtful and non-satirical post in response to an editor’s query about a Katrina parody is something everyone should read. Ott’s reply to the editor is a sensitive, thoughtful, and damning indictment of society, government, and the media. Here’s a sample:
The victims of Katrina are not really the victims of Katrina herself. The tragedy began long before the hurricane hit.
Natural disasters have always happened and always will. While, mercifully, they don’t occur every day in every place, they are common enough that we ought to have an expectation that bad things can and will happen. We need to cultivate the inner resources in ourselves, our children and our neighborhoods to cope with the inevitable. When we cede that power and responsibility to the federal government, we surrender a part of what makes us human and leave ourselves more vulnerable to the tempest.
I can’t agree with the editor’s statement that Katrina survivors are heroes, simply by virtue of having survived a natural disaster. I think Ott’s response to her was very restrained. Many people did perform many acts of heroism during and after the storm. But I really do believe that those who stayed when they could have left, including some dear friends, were idiots, not heroes. I understand that not everyone had the capability to evacuate for various reasons, and I’m not talking about those folks. I’m talking about those who chose to “ride it out” out of some sense of personal invincibility or magical thinking. Those people were a burden that others had to carry, and I can’t call them heroes. Precious resources were spent rescuing people who could have evacuated, and others suffered because of it. And the others, who had to stay because they lacked options, are not heroes. They were victims of a natural disaster. Nothing more. To call both of these groups of people heroes cheapens the word.
A Hat tip goes to the Anchoress for this story, in a post which also includes info on the real chill wind that could silence free speech, as opposed to gasbag Tim Robbins’ chill wind.
Link to Pursuing Holiness and track back your latest and greatest here!
Trackback using Linkfest Haven Deluxe.
Trackposted to Perri Nelson’s Website, Is It Just Me?, The Random Yak, Don Surber, Adam’s Blog, basil’s blog, Madman Returns, Stuck On Stupid, The Amboy Times, The Bullwinkle Blog, Jo’s Cafe, Conservative Cat, Pet’s Garden Blog, Rightwing Guy, 123 Beta, The HILL Chronicles, third world county, Faultline USA, Wake Up America, Woman Honor Thyself, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, stikNstein… has no mercy, The World According to Carl, Blue Star Chronicles, Pirate’s Cove, The Right Nation, The Pink Flamingo, Dumb Ox News, bRight & Early, and Right Voices, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.
Happy New Year
The victims of Katrina are not really the victims of Katrina herself. The tragedy began long before the hurricane hit…so true..and I know I worked with them!..great post ty for the link and..HAPPY RAINY NEW YORK NEW YEARS!..lol..:-)
I linked to you from Now a time for perspective on our occupation but the TB doesn’t show. Am I caught in your spam filter?
Bernie, yes, you were - not sure why Akismet doesn’t like you, but I keep marking your trackbacks as “not spam” and it doesn’t seem to learn. Sorry about that.