Jena 6: Bell's Bail Denied, Aggravated Ignorance

Just on CNN – Mychal Bell’s bail was denied.

The big “Jena 6″ protest is over, Sharpton and Jackson got their glory, at the expense of people who did the work, including Mychal Bell’s lawyers. The media played it like a faith-based event, even using the word “pilgrimage” repeatedly. Mid-day, the news reported that Mychal Bell will have another bond-hearing. That had absolutely nothing to do with the protest, Al Sharpton, or Jesse Jackson. It was just fortuitous timing. Nobody paid attention to the dog that didn’t bark:

It had many of the signs of the early civil rights protests — militant slogans, upraised clenched fists and multitudes of police — but none of the hate and fear-drenched campaigns in Selma, Little Rock and Montgomery.

Could that possibly be, because in spite of the fact that there is still injustice, it’s no longer public policy and that takes the heat and the urgency out of it? Why yes, it could. A lot of change has taken place in the last 40 years. Not enough, as evidenced by the morons who put nooses on the back of their pickup truck and drove around the protesters trying to start trouble.

police in nearby Alexandria said they arrested two whites after officers noticed a pair of nooses dangling from the rear of the driver’s pickup truck.

The driver, identified as 18-year-old Jeremiah Munsen of Colfax, was charged with inciting a riot, driving while intoxicated and contributing to the delinquency of a juvenile, authorities said. A city attorney will decide whether charges against the 16-year-old passenger from Dry Prong are warranted, said Alexandria Police Sgt. Clifford Gatlin.

“I wish we had a charge in Louisiana for aggravated ignorance, because this is a classic case,” Gatlin said.

Lot of that going around… but less than there used to be, and I’m hopeful for the future. In this case, CNN reports that Munsen was arrested for inciting a riot.

I originally started blogging about the Jena 6 because I was outraged at the 2nd degree attempted murder charges. I thought then they should receive “at most” time served, although my opinion has changed since then. I think it’s wrong – and I think it was deliberate – they were kept in adult court, even after the charges were lowered. I’ve posted my concerns about the jury – not that it was composed of white people, but at their possible connections to the prosecution. I was unimpressed with Justin Barker’s testimony, and his injuries. I spent time studying other cases that were relevant. I’ve been infuriated by DOJ attorney Donald Washington (who lied again on CNN last night) and frustrated by those who invoke the Gospel of Washington. In short, I’ve spent far too much time on this case. And I’ll be spending even more, because I’m now in possession of documents and details that the media has chosen not to cover; more on that on Monday.

Over time my opinion of what punishment is appropriate for the Jena 6 has changed, and I’ve gone from “at most” time served in that original post to just wanting to see fair trials in the juvenile system and letting the chips fall where they may. But there are no easy answers in this case, and those who make a poster boy of Mychal Bell as the symbol of racial injustice should find another symbol. To put him on a pedestal is yet another type of aggravated ignorance. The point isn’t the person, the point is whether the original charges were appropriate and fair. Although I have a great deal of sympathy for Alan Bean, I think he’s dangerously naive to call the Jena 6 “fine young men.”

Part of the reason I’ve taken all this so personally is my own family’s racial history. And to follow up on that post, although we were able to get L into an experimental cancer treatment program at Duke University last spring, the treatment didn’t work for her and she died on Tuesday. I haven’t been able to write about it before now. I can barely think about it. Please keep her family – her blood relatives and my family, her adopted family – in your prayers.

The Jena 6 Media Circus and Alan Bean

It seemed from the news coverage that the whole world converged on Jena today. But this blog post really caught my attention. Alan Bean was, as far as I know, the first guy on this story. CNN gave him a photo credit for his photo of the “white tree” – and then promptly cut to Al Sharpton. Bean wrote -

When I showed up at Antioch Baptist church, I remembered the first organizing meeting when I was the only person from outside Jena in the room. This time, the church had been comandeered by VH1 and I was told I could not enter. Instead, Salt and Peppa (remember them) were inside interviewing the Jena 6 parents while fully uniformed members of the New Black Panther Party patrolled outside. It was a cartoon–something I didn’t particularly want to be associated with. I have no beef with these people–but why are they suddenly in charge? And why have the folks who stood by the families when no one else would listen been so rudely thrust aside. I know I’m not supposed to focus on these questions–but I have watched this movie before–in Tulia, Texas.

Whether or not you agree with Bean – and I don’t agree with him on every issue, not by a long shot – that’s just sad. I believe he is an honest and honorable man, devoting his life to what he sincerely thinks is right. And to be callously shut out of something that he has put so much time and energy into, and worked so hard to keep going, is wrong.

Jena 6: Another Day, Another Outage – Liveblogging CNN Coverage

Traffic is just too high for comments – in spite of the RAM upgrade it’s taking out client sites. The protest is today and CNN is giving it a lot of airtime – I think the traffic will slow down enough tomorrow to bring them back on. However, I’d like to take the opportunity to clarify a few things:

  • If the Jena 6 are found guilty in a fair trial for beating Justin Barker, then they need to be punished. That’s for you commenters who say all charges should be dropped and they should be set free.
  • They should be punished appropriately. Not for crimes they may commit in the future – that’s for you commenters who say they need to be “taken off the street before they do worse” and for you “hang those savages” commenters.
  • Not everyone in Jena is a racist. Some of the protesters are racist.
  • There are legitimate reasons to question whether D.A. Reed Walters engaged in selective prosecution, and whether Mychal Bell’s trial was fair.
  • There are legitimate reasons to question whether the original charges were fair and appropriate.
  • Justin Barker did not hang the nooses. His friends did. Even if he HAD hung the nooses, that’s not an excuse to beat him several months later. Justin Barker may or may not have called Robert Bailey a nigger and laughed at him for having his ass whipped. Even if he did, that’s not an excuse to beat him.
  • The noose-hangers, Justin Barker, and the Jena 6 were all minors. Teenagers. A group not known for good judgment and common sense. The root of the problem in this situation is the adults.
  • The American flag that CNN is showing that the Jena 6 protesters put where the “white tree” was is UPSIDE DOWN. That’s no coincidence. You just lost a LOT of sympathy from me, just like the illegal alien protesters did for the same disrespect to the flag.

When comments come back on, they will be registration only, in the hope that the worst of the racists, on both sides, won’t bother. Comments will still be moderated, as well. This march is certainly a crescendo, but it’s not the end of the situation, and a lot of things still have to happen before it is fully resolved. New information will come out, some of it on this blog. It is my hope that we can have a civil, and useful discussion about it.

There are literally dozens of Jena 6 posts in the archive that include every detail I could find about the case going back to the beginning. Here are a few with lots of links and info:

The Jena 6: Nooses Hang From The “White Tree” – a good place to start with a summary of the entire case.
The Jena 6: Since When Do Teenage Boys Watch Lonesome Dove? – the first Jena 6 post on this blog
Jena Six: Justin Barker Testifies at Mychal Bell Trial
Jena 6: More Testimony, Going To The Jury UPDATED – More on the testimony in the case including Justin Barkers injuries, which were NOT severe.
Jena 6: A Primer To The Racial Unrest In Jena, Louisiana – A who’s who in the Jena Six case. This has been copied and posted in many places.
Jena 6: Sentencing and Hope for Mychal Bell – The Louisiana Supreme Court overturned a conviction very similar to Mychal Bell’s.
Jena 6: Update and Background Info – How’d they get an all white jury? Was it deliberate?
Jena 6: Cross Burnings = Noose Hangings? – Prometheus 6 noted that cross burnings are illegal. Wouldn’t that also cover nooses?
Jena 6: Sentencing Delayed, DOJ Conducts Forum – the DOJ finally made it to Jena, but it was the PR division, not the civil rights division.
The Jena 6: Update on Mychal Bell – his status as of 8/19/07
____________________

I’ve got CNN on and I’ll be blogging on some of their coverage.

2:08 – Mos Def interview. Citizen of the world? This is a national security issue? What has this guy been smoking? Oh please… maybe that explains the sunglasses. He’s mentioning the stories of the Confederate flags – it should be noted that a commenter yesterday said CNN showed yesterday that is flying in a town near Jena – not in Jena. It should also be noted that on several white supremacist message boards (I have google alerts on all topics Jena) they intended to be in Jena today as well. So all Confederate flag flying can’t be attributed to Jena residents – outsiders have come to stir up trouble. He says “the responsible thing to do” is to free the Jena 6. I object to the concept that because Justin Barker is fine today, there should be no penalty whatsoever for the attack. I believe his injuries were minor, I’ve contended that all along. But the attitude of the law CAN’T be “no harm, no foul.”

3:24 – The 3rd District Court of Appeals says that Mychal Bell needs to be brought to the LaSalle Parish courthouse for a hearing within the next 72 hours. The explanation, however, for why he is still being held is that bail was denied and the case is still under appeal, as far as the latest I’ve read. Duh. CNN should KNOW this.

7:57 – Donald Washington just said that Mychal Bell had 4 battery convictions.  WRONG AGAIN, Donald!  Good grief, is there anything this guy can get right?  Bell’s had two battery convictions.  And two convictions on criminal damage to property.  Not four battery convictions.  This guy is driving me up a wall.  He sounds reasonable, and I want to agree with him, then he either lies or makes a mistake – but the mistake is always in the favor of the prosecution.  Well, he’s entitled to his opinion but not his own facts.  No, two fewer battery convictions don’t make Bell an altar boy.  But as I’ve said repeatedly throughout all of this, the truth is bad enough – don’t dramatize it.  Or lie about it.

Teen Sentenced To Five Years For Baseball Bat Beating

Teen Sentenced To Five Years For Baseball Bat Beating

BATES COUNTY — A Bates County teenager will spend five years in prison for attacking another teen with a baseball bat.

No one knows why Bryan Murphy, 18, attacked Isaiah Stapleton last year, hitting him several times with a baseball bat. Murphy pleaded guilty to assault and armed criminal action.

The judge told Murphy that it’s only by the grace of god that this wasn’t a murder trial and sentenced him to five years in prison with no chance of parole.

“I feel five years is something to get the message across that what he did is not okay because I feel he tried to murder my son,” David Stapleton said.

A big hat tip to Ken for the story.

As Roach correctly pointed out in another comment thread, the plural of anecdote is not data. Still, I find it interesting how this crime is being treated compared to Justin Barker’s beating. As far as I know, there have been no studies comparing charges and sentences of white criminals vs. black criminals.

Check out the website for Isaiah, the victim of the attack.